Fulgora Replicators

by Klaudia

Self-replicating machines hold islands far out across Fulgora.

Content
4 hours ago
2.1
1.07K
Factorio: Space Age Icon Space Age Mod
Planets Combat Enemies

g AI slop

a month ago
(updated a month ago)

AI slop, probably made by Claude ai cause of the nickname, its supposed to be marked as vibe coded

a month ago

In addition to marking this as genai, I would also like them to post the link to their github home, like at the end of the day unless Wube bans AI mods, then there will be claude made mods, but transparency should be a community requirement. Ideally with the open source cause it's already embedded in the download, you can't really hide the source. It's an MIT license for some reason so it's fully open to whatever people want to do with it.

a month ago

Cause seriously, if people are making these things with claude, the more important thing is to have them show their process to make the community better, if people have issues with this then they don't have to play the mod. Authors need to be open about how they are doing this because many of us want to help actual people make good stuff.

a month ago

Man, why you gotta break my heart with the news like this

a month ago

First of all, that's just funny. You're accusing the author of completely vibe-coding the mod when not a single one of you has published a single mod on the portal.

Second, if you understand at least something about Lua or coding in general, you can simply download the mod and check it yourself.

This mod looks like it was mostly made by a human, and as I said, you can check it yourself. It doesn't have any obvious markers of AI-generated code, and even if AI assisted during development, the author clearly knows what they're doing if they were able to guide it that well.

Third, and most importantly, you've been using AI-made or AI-assisted apps for years at this point in almost every part of your life. AI is a tool, and you still have to know how to use it properly. Even if something was assisted by AI, that doesn't automatically make it "bad" just because AI was involved. You should judge the actual product, not the tool that may have been used to make it.

And by the way, this mod is very cleverly optimized, and I was genuinely impressed by it. Huge congrats to Klaudia! Keep it going, mate!

a month ago
(updated a month ago)

Agree with eRisel. Just stop whining and either use mod or not, nobody cares if you don't like that it is made with AI, it's just your issue. Many good things made with AI, many bad things made with AI. Many bugs made in good products with AI, many bugs made in good products without AI, it's not a problem of a tool. If the whole mod made with AI (fully vibe-coded) and it is good - it is good no matter what and it is a good work.

P.S.
Respect to Klaudia for making really good mods, appreciate it and wish to go on.

a month ago
(updated a month ago)

gng who cares about ai ? ppl just hate " FUN "

slop and vibecoded ur 4ss.

15 days ago
(updated 15 days ago)

What's the point if following a mod development if it's developed with AI?
Like, what is the intrinsic value it provides to you?

When you are product-oriented - whether you've used AI or not - doesn't matter.

But modding for me is about people.

I agree that Klaudia's mods need a good disclosure of AI tools usage.
Just so we can know which things actually took you effort instead of money/tokens.
Otherwise what we are admiring is not Klaudia's creativity - but how advanced LLMs got there days.

Which is obvious.

If we are all product-oriented - what's the point of having actual people having fun and making mods, if AI can make it better?
Excuse me, but even in the name of productivity, I want to have actual people in the loop.
I want to see their mistakes and them growing communities and following around them, while they try their hardest.
It's not only about performance - it's about you (the dev) and you (the player).

AI is a tool. But not all usage is neccessarily good.
We need a disclosure - the more precise - the better.

15 days ago

And to address any claims - I've made mods (personal usage).
And I have friends doing mods as well (Anenzoras, for example)

15 days ago

Just so you understand the gravity - mod introduces a ton of new sprites, but no artist is credited.

For me this means that even graphics are AI generated.

And it's not disclosed - this means Klaudia clearly don't respect that a lot of people in the community like mods, because they are not only fun - but pretty.
In fact, replicating Earendel's style is really hard, and just an attempt is admirable.
There's nothing to admire if it's done by AI.

And with no AI usage disclosure - there is also no respect for people, who would be glad to learn from you - how you've coded something.
So it's disrespectful to anyone who admires mods for their programming and optimizations.

As a game designer, I don't admire when someone is so sneakily disrespectful to the audience they are trying to appeal to.

15 days ago
(updated 15 days ago)

TLDR:
1) Author does not need to mark it's mod with "AI mark" just because you want it - it's too naive to expect people to do what you want them to do just because you want it and when it has no strong reason to be done (it has not);

2) Opinion that "work of art" approach when making mods and other software is lost due to AI caused by misunderstanding how AI actually works and how much effort it takes to make something really good even with strong LLMs - try to do something like this with your own hands, share it with people and you'll understand;

It looks like you treat mods like a "work of art", but it doesn't mean that mod author should treat it the same way you expect it to be treated. You also try to assume that author using strong LLM does not use "it's own" creativity - seems like the statement of a person who either did not tried to make it's own production-ready software (firstly, mods are a software) or graphics with LLMs and do not actually has idea how much effort it takes to make something really good and polished that will look and work like a "work of art".

More about losing "work of art" approach:

As an example, photos did not kill the visual arts when got massively spread and now we all use photos instead of hand-drawing people, objects and landscapes - two things that initially were about the same but occupied different niches and coexist nowadays. It's not a problem of a tool (AI in our case).

P.S.
"And it's not disclosed - this means Klaudia clearly don't respect that a lot of people in the community like mods, because they are not only fun - but pretty."
"So it's disrespectful to anyone who admires mods for their programming and optimizations."
etc.
No one is obligated to show respect to others just because they are humiliated by something/someone. You either do cool things and people respect you for that (for what you give them) or not. Just grow up.

14 days ago

Subjective morality police on the loose, WEE WOO WEE WOO.

Keep going Klaudia, flak is heaviest directly over the target :D

14 days ago
(updated 14 days ago)

To be fair, the main issue with AI mods from what I've been told is that they tend to be a little buggy, poor optimised, and have poor long-term support.

I just tried out one of Klaudia's other mods, The Beast, and it has a lot of... issues. Until it's updated to fix them, we can't meaningfully comment on whether it'll maintain long term support or not and fit those stereotypes.

I largely agree with DarkJune's comments regarding product-oriented mods. If you're just making mods because the idea seems cool and it would be nice to see in game, instead of thinking about whether the mod will actually do be fun to play with, you end up with mods that don't actually do anything for anyone. Again, not relevant strictly to this mod but instead to this author, but their beast mod has no long term meaningful engagement or reason to use, it's like a gag gift that you buy cheap, look at once, then throw away.

I presume this is primarily why people want things marked as AI. For those who don't care and even like AI, an AI mark on a mod should mean nothing - Resisting it is a self admission that AI products are of lower quality and you are concerned about long term engagement, rather than whether your mod is actually good or not. And for those who don't like AI exactly for the reasons I wrote above, they'll be able to immediately identify whether a mod is likely to be abandoned post release and not receive updates.

I don't think AI mods should be banned. Of course AI has come a long way and is integrated heavily into a lot of people's lives, and is very strong at programming, but I do still think they should be marked and identified so users can more accurately assess the things they're downloading, even if that assessment is only slightly improved by the mark.

EDIT: I've now tested this mod in particular and it seems good so far, like it could be used for a full run, but this was only with an hours worth of testing and using a few console commands.

7 days ago

I have to agree with DarkJune and Indoor-Swimming.

As Indoor-Swimming said, a lable that shows if something is made using AI shouldnt be something bad for those that dont care if it was made with AI. Its just something that other that do mind can see and decide if they want to use it or not.

Its sad that there are people who doesnt understand how bad AI is for the industry. At least this generative AI stuff. AI wont get removed entirely from our lives but it should be something optional and not forced onto everyone like versuffer wants it to be.

Also I cant say if this mod is AI slop, bc i dont have the needed information about it. But if Klaudia has any interest of doing anything FOR the community will she tell us if she used AI and for what. Bc if not then she doesnt what to be part for the modding community but rather just some quick and dirty attention like AI will give you.

7 days ago

To be made with AI, if it is, is pretty damn impressive in my opinion. The author clearly knows their way around Lua and Blender, which is more than what a lot of people who have made a lot of mods on the portal can say they have. I have used AI to try and make models in the past and well, it's not good, and if it is, I haven't used that. The models made for these mods have some incredible quality to them.

I honestly wouldn't mind there to be an AI disclosure, but to what extent? Did it help make a debug, correct some code, make an asset, at what point does a mod become AI slop if only less than 5% of it had some AI involvement? Or are you people some religious fanatics that just boycott anything that has to do with AI? Seems rather inhumane to just downplay anyone's efforts just b/c "AI" when advanced algorithms have been a factor in our lives for the past two decades.

23 hours ago

Nobody cares if its made with AI or not, if its a good mod. Who gives a damn. AI vibe coding makes ideas from anyone become reality. Being against this is just stupid.

18 hours ago
(updated 18 hours ago)

While I am concerned over the use of generative AI in passion-driven pursuits like modding, and agree with the flagging of or outright banning of mods made predominantly or entirely with generative AI, in this specific case I am a little confused. I can't seem to find any sign of this particular mod being made with it within its code, besides the author's name being similar to a popular large-language model. As I doubt your suspicions are founded entirely on that, I'm curious how you came to the conclusion that it was made using that.

Though, generally speaking, I think one step that could be helpful to spotting mods made with generative AI even if it's not required to be directly disclosed would be a requirement for a visible repo of some sort, such as a github or notabug, that shows the mod's contributors.

New response