Filter inserters do not work without filters even when not connected to circuit network (in "whitelist" mode). This is not the case for pumps. Because there is no separate filter pumps, they shouldn't require a filter to work by default, so "no filter" means allow any fluid, regardless of wether "no filter" is chosen manually or comes from circuit network.
Based on what was announced in FFF-393 and FFF-405, although it was not said what the default pump behaviour will be, I'm not really sure that this should be changed.
I'd suggest using Enable/Disable in your case (possibly with another pump that has filter) or just send some other fluid as filter instead of empty signal