Planet Express


Cross-planet delivery that just works. GOOD NEWS EVERYONE! Moving goods between planets means babysitting platform schedules and cargo requests by hand. Planet Express does it for you. Enrol a few cargo ships, tell each planet what it needs, and the mod finds the goods, picks a ship, and flies them over — no schedule micromanagement, ever.

Utilities
3 days ago
2.0 - 2.1
1.44K
Logistics Logistic network

i Ships running the same routes while other planets starve

5 months ago
(updated 5 months ago)

Cool mod! I hate managing ship delivery schedules. However, I'm struggling to make it work like I'd want it to.

Ships prefer to run 300 science (not even a full rocket) from Vulcanus to Nauvis, while Gleba is sitting there with 45 items waiting for a ship to deliver them.

The problem is that science is continuously consumed on Nauvis, so by the time the delivery completes, the ship decides to go pick up another 300 as they're produced.

Meanwhile I've got hundreds of basebuilding items requested on Gleba and none of my 4 ships are going there.

Maybe a better heuristic would be to prefer full rockets or something? Or prefer delivering to places that have a larger number of outstanding requests?

I realized that I could lower the number of ships per route to 1 or something, which would guarantee a ship per-planet. Is that the intended way to ensure ships are distributed among planets equally? Or do I just need a way larger fleet?

5 months ago

Great diagnosis - you've nailed it. Right now the fleet has no fairness between planets: it serves them in a fixed order each tick, and a planet that's constantly consuming something on a short route (your Vulcanus→Nauvis science) keeps grabbing ships the moment they free up, before the longer Gleba run ever gets one. Per-item priority won't help here - it only orders items within one planet, not across planets.

Lowering max-ships-per-route is a legit way to force distribution today (it stops all 4 ships piling onto the science loop) - it's just coarse, since it caps every route. A bigger fleet helps a bit but doesn't remove the bias.

The real fix is anti-starvation scheduling so no planet gets ignored, plus an option to skip sub-rocket loads so ships don't burn trips on 300 science. I'm going to add that in v1.8.0 - thanks for the detailed write-up, this is exactly the kind of case that's easy to miss. 🙂

5 months ago

GOOD NEWS EVERYONE!
v1.8.0 has been released with this fix.

a month ago

not so much it would seem. i set minimum to export to a rocket load, 1000 units. i have three ships all hanging out around the planet constantly requesting 300 units, less than a rocket load and before the rocket is loaded they drop the request so the robots all put the science back in the warehouse. only for the ships to request again and the process starts all over again

15 days ago

Thanks, this is a real bug, and it's fixed in 2.1.10 (Factorio 2.1).

As robots carried the science into the rocket silo, those packs left the logistic network. The fleet saw the planet's stock drop below your minimum and decided it could no longer spare any, so it cancelled the request. The robots then unloaded the silo, the stock reappeared, and the ship asked again. From 2.1.10, the amount a ship is sent for is fixed once it's dispatched, so the request no longer changes while the rocket loads.

About the 300: the minimum-to-export settings (the minimum trip size and the reserve) only decide whether the source planet has enough to export. They don't set how much a ship takes. A ship takes what the destination is short of. If Nauvis is short 300 science, the ship asks for 300. To ship full rocket loads, open the destination's landing pad, go to the Trade tab and set the science pack's threshold to 1000. The pad then waits until it's short at least 1000 and asks for all of it in one trip. The "minimum cargo load (%)" setting is a percentage of the ship's hold, not of a rocket, so it won't do this. I described it badly in the 1.8.0 reply.

13 days ago

my current run isn't up to needing it yet so it may be a while before i can test it out. thanks for the update. i will be sure to test as soon as im able.

New response