Hey, thanks for the quick response! I double-checked the settings for Angel's Refining and all of the Angel Ores were disabled in the starting area.
:facepalm:
I have Seablock running on an alternate save and I think that disabled them, and they didn't get re-enabled when I tried to generate a new save. I'll just reset my mod settings. I really wish I'd caught that before I made this post lol