Hey,
glad you like it :)
The import button currently only supports importing of tasks that have been exported with todo list itself.
You have two options:
1: do the migration by hand by recreating every task in todo list and then copy/paste the contents from notepad
2: you can try to "fake" a todo list export by creating the json yourself and then base64 encode it and then try to import it.
The JSON template to use should be
[{ "task": "your task", "title": "your task title}, {...}]
If you need support with this or more details feel free to ask :)
Doing custom import is something I would like to support but is really hard to do unfortunately :/