Hey themonsterflag,
I had the exact same issue you are describing. This is due to a combination of newer mod versions that I believe are not compatible with the current "Touched by an Angel" Pyanodon's fix version. When I checked, I realised there were also a number of mods that actually did not get activated, while I was under the impression all mods loaded successfully due to a lack of errors.
I think the best solution is to have a look at the previous thread here on the discussion board, as I am currently successfully playing a game. The solution is to use the ModMyFactory program and load the .FMP file that the modpack creater made available in the latest version, that will allow you to download the specific versions that he verified to be working well and he has been using in his own playthrough. Unfortunately you cannot install specific older versions through the ingame mod browser, so this seems like the best solution at present.
Good luck!