I don't see how TrainAdmirer could not replicate the problem. As I type, I am staring at a fresh base game with only base and Speed Control Scaled enabled and the buttons are bugged. By that, I mean if I push one of the slow buttons then the speed will go to x.5 and after that none of them work at all, neither slow nor fast. But I can respect real life taking a priority over his time. I do not have the mod experience to fix such things.
The hotkeys of Shift + and - work. I don't know about the others as I don't use them. Note that the + and - are the keys next to Backspace and not the ones in the Numpad.